Friday, February 27, 2009

Urban vs. Suburban Teachers

EdWeek recently featured a story about a large survey of teachers and principals. The survey, sponsored by MetLife, was originally given after the publication of A Nation at Risk. The headline of the article was regarding the improvement in teacher satisfaction over the past 25 years, but the survey contains a great deal more information. The write-up is essentially a summary of the survey results and covers 191 pages, but what I find most interesting are the differences between teachers in urban vs. suburban schools.

Here are just a few examples (I've summarized the questions):

For how many students is lack of parent support a hindranace?
Less than a quarter:
Urban - 35%
Suburban 59%

How much of a problem is it to get qualified teachers in your school?
Very or Somewhat Serious:
Urban 40%
Suburban 19%
(Principals were 39/20)

How much of a problem is teacher turnover in your school?
Very or Somewhat Serious:
Urban 48%
Suburban 23%
(Principals were 32/14)

None of these results are too terribly surprising -- and I'm guessing they'd be more dramatic had they limited the comparison sample to those who said they taught in "inner-city" schools rather than all urban schools. On other questions, of course, answers weren't all that different. But I question the utility of generalizing to all teachers when sub-groups differ so greatly. Can we really say "x% of teachers . . ." in any meaningful way?

Methodological Note
Among the 1000 teachers surveyed, 13% said they taught in an inner-city school, 14% in an urban school (which were lumped together as urban), 36% in a suburban school, 19% in a small town school, 16% in a rural school (which were lumped together to make rural), and 1% didn't know. Which leaves us with 27% urban, 36% suburban, 35% rural. But after they weighted the responses to match demographics they came up with: 27% urban, 23% suburban, 49% rural.

1 comment:

information technology said...

First of all thanks to you for sharing this interesting, informative and impressive article with us. I have really very enjoyed to reading it. Do you know that in well organized classes: time, materials and space are used efficiently. This will increase the opportunities for participation, and will make it easier for teachers. Indeed, a well organized class facilitates the efforts of the teacher to establish contacts with particular students while teaching the whole class. How to organize the space? Lesson plan archive: Some teachers use lesson plans saved on the computer. They archive their lesson plans so that they can be easily modified the following year. Set a specific time for all students to clean and organize their desks and lockers. Let your students move around the classroom in a natural way. They feel less anxious. Establish guts(.)pk/shop/category/art-supplies/pencils/ habits to manage personal and classroom materials, to record homework, to do and return it to the teacher, to distribute and pick up assigned assignments, and to enter school and class and get out.